The day the piano went silent
72Musician and visionary
Exactly 20 years ago today my brother, jazz pianist, composer, band leader, arranger, and visionary, left us after a painful struggle with cancer. He was older than me by almost exactly seven years. His name was Chris McGregor and he and his musicians between them put out some of the most amazing jazz, in trio, small group, and big band formats.
Chris was much more than a musician, though. He really was a visionary. Even the name of his big band, the Brotherhood of Breath, spoke about his vision. He was passionately committed to freedom, not only in the music, but in his home country of South Africa, which he left with his small group, the Blue Notes, in 1964, when apartheid was tightening its grip on the bodies and minds of the people.
Facing his death
I have written about him elsewhere so would just like to add here a paragraph from an article on him by renowned British jazz journalist Graham Lock, from his book Chasing the Vibration (1994). Lock interviewed Chris in September 1984.
“Chris McGregor looks more hippy sage than African. A tall, stocky, cheerful man with humorous eyes and a ready smile, his most distinctive features are a long grey beard and even longer grey hair worn in a ponytail that hangs all the way down to his ample waist. But African he is.”
Chris's widow, Maxine, wrote a book of her life with Chris. This was published in the US by Bamberger Books of Flint, Michigan, in 1995, and was called Chris McGregor and the Brotherhood of Breath, and subtitled “My Life with a South African Jazz Pioneer.”
Maxine wrote of Chris's philosophy of life:
“Because he was able to really accept life in its entirety, to accept all that came his way, to let go and not set such store on results (a philosophy of 'Whatever happens is the story'), Chris was able to take his life – and death – with a lightness, an expansiveness and a sense of humour that led to peace.”
And she wrote of her own experience of Chris's death:
“Certainly facing his death with him – because he seemed so much like a prolongation of myself – was identical to facing my own death, something that I had always avoided doing even with the deaths of my parents. It was an indescribable experience that has made me fear death no longer – Chris was making jokes ten minutes before he died – and gave me the courage not to hold myself back from life. For if you no longer fear death what is there to fear?”
The day he died
The day Chris died my then wife Joan and I were about to fly to France to be with him and his family. We realised that the situation was serious. We had been in daily telephonic contact with Maxine and she and Chris knew of our plans to come to them.
The 26th May 1990 was also our father's birthday and so that morning we were getting ready to celebrate with him before flying out that evening when the call came from Maxine to say that Chris had just left us. To say we were shattered would be a vast understatement. I had spoken to Chris just a few evenings before and he had said, in his usual funny way, “I've been to the angels and they told me they weren't ready for me yet.”
In the interview with Lock Chris spoke of his inspiration, what kept him going: “I guess you have to approach it with your instincts, just grab hold of whatever's coming and follow it through.
“Really, that's all. That is a musician's work. It's a great life, too. I wouldn't edit my story at all. When I think back there's nothing I regret, nothing that seems to me to have been wrong or off-key.
“You have to b e 50 years old to realise, though. That's maybe something there is to regret, that we get too soon old and too late smart.”
We went to France, to the Moulin de Madone, where Chris and Maxine had lived since 1973 in the South West, where we all tried to support each other in our grief and loss. Wherever we looked there were reminders of that great spirit who had lived there, and who had made such great music, and brought so much joy to others with that music.
And I was grateful to have known him, to have called him, in blood and in spirit, my brother.
This little poem is by way of my tribute to him, my remembrance of his African-ness, so it is writtne somewhat in the style of a traditional Xhosa praise poem and using, in typical call and response style, two little phrases from two Xhosa songs, Thula Sana (Sleep my Child) and Thula Sizwe (Be still, My People).
The day the piano went silent
The day the piano went silent
thula sana
the day the piano stopped singing
thula sana
the day your fingers stopped dancing
thula sana
that day our hearts went quiet
thula sizwe
Now the piano song is stilled
thula sana
And our hearts are stilled with pain
thula sana
We long to hear that song again
thula sana
The way our ears were filled
thula sizwe
The way our ears were filled
thula sana
With the song of the beating heart
thula sana
But now that heart is stilled
thula sana
The heart that gave us love
thula sizwe
O brother of mine, I miss you so
thula sana
My sister is weeping also
thula sana
Your songs are still in our hearts
thula sana
And their rhythms still mark our paths
thula sizwe
The hills and valleys of our youth
thula sana
Are waiting for the song's rebirth
thula sana
And the wind blowing over the hills
thula sana
Still cries out your name to the earth
thula sizwe.
You left us before we were ready
thula sana
Before we knew how to sing
thula sana
But now in our sadness we sing
thula sana
And the people will join our song
thula sizwe
Copyright Notice
The text and all images on this page, unless otherwise indicated, are by Tony McGregor who hereby asserts his copyright on the material. Should you wish to use any of the text or images feel free to do so with proper attribution and, if possible, a link back to this page. Thank you.
© Tony McGregor 2010
vote upvote downsharePrintflag
- Useful (2)
- Funny
- Awesome (1)
- Beautiful (14)
- Interesting
CommentsLoading...
A wonderful tribute and honor for others to hear his story and that of his family.
Beautiful, and very touching. Your life was enhanced by someone very special. You will meet agan.
Thanks, Tony....very touching.
Your friendship and love come out loud and clear, and although your loss was great, it is evident that your friend still lives on. Beautiful poem.
This reminded me of my father who also played the piano, among other instruments. He loved the piano, I believe the most. I hope wherever he is, he knows just how missed he is. Beautiful message here. (: v
Beautiful tribute - your poem squeezes the heart.
Music is one of the best gifts we have been dealt with. To have a sibling become great at it is even more of a gift. Top that off with being a great human being makes it a gift that is immeasurable. I have always loved jazz; especially the piano and sax. I am glad his music continues.
best regards,
Thank you Tony! I hope you and your family will be reunited some day and maybe I can hang out and listen to your brother as well! Thank you Sir!
Tony, how sad to have farewelled your brother long before any of you were ready. Somehow, his own words are so positive and comforting, something we should all be able to say one day: "It's a great life, too. I wouldn't edit my story at all. When I think back there's nothing I regret, nothing that seems to me to have been wrong or off-key."
How privileged to have had him as a brother ... you and your family will always be able to dance and walk to his music. And what a beautiful tribute your poem is ... I can hear the beat and the words, I am from Africa, after all. RIP Chris ...
A wonderful tribute to Chris. I'm sorry that I only knew of him and didn't actually know him personally! Yet somehow through his music I felt as though I knew him as a person.
What a touching story Tony. And I loved the names Brotherhood of Breath and Blue Notes. What lovely names for a musical band. I think I understand your pain and leave you to it until the right time provides the salve. May he rest in peace.
Beautiful elegy. Beauty of soul seems to run in your family. As Mother Teresa said, "Holiness grows fast where there is kindness. I have never heard of kind souls going astray. The world is lost for want of sweetness and kindness."
Thanks for sharing your brother. His music and memories live on in you.
Being a musician myself I can appreciate this heartfelt hub very much and the Poem was awesome, thanks for sharing his story with us.
Tony, such a beautiful story, not to have any fear of death
must surely come from inner faith, knowing there is a better
place for all people who love God.
Thank You for sharing his life with us.
What a great way to have lived life- and then to leave it on such a happy note- our deepest condolences. Am sure he has read and felt your beautiful poem too.
Thank you, Tony, for this hub, a great tribute to your brother. I met him in 1986 at the Leipzig Jazz Festival where he played a wonderful solo concert, your hub brought also back some memories.
Beautiful tribute, thanks for sharing.
It's hard losing family; the world seems never the same again, but he obviously knew how to live life when he had it.
This was a wonderful tribute to your brother. I am sure you will forever miss him. Such an awful disease. Thank you for sharing this hub with us and giving us a share in your grief. God Bless.
Thank you Tony for sharing and enriching - I join you in the eternal song - peace and love - Chris A
This is very lovely and quite touching Tony. And you mention something that is so very true...perhaps it is at around age 50 that many people start to reflect and realize that life is speeding by too fast and it's time to look back and see if there are any regrets.
Thank you for sharing this fabulous tribute to your brother, and thank you for bringing out such a universal truth that we all have to face at some point in life. Your poem is beautiful. :)
Your poem is so moving, Tony. And what a wonderful tribute to your brother - your hub is a symphony of love and caring!
What a beautiful tribute to your brother. Very touching! Talent clearly runs in the family.
This is an amazing tribute. Your poem at the end is quite touching. The way your brother faced death with courage and even a sense of humor speaks volumes about what kind of person he was. Thank you for this piece. I am moved by it. I love music and I love musicians.
Hello Tony, I spend most of my time in south west france and this very month is jazz time there ! My brother spent his last months there before going back to jersey to die and how sad hearing him say to his 14 year old son "well,I am pleased with you son ! my jobs finished now". His name was John and never in my life had I heard him serious.His humerous nature kept many going... Hearing your story about Chris brought back memories from 4 years ago-still fresh.A good example to us all your story of Chris and his musical spirit and when I hear the piano in jazz I will surely think of Chris,
Dear Tony, as I was reading I was swept with all kinds of different emotions. I lost pets and grandparents. That hurts. I've never lost a brother or sister. That must be beyond the endurable, especially when pre-mature. But I only started identifying with Chris, after you told us he had no fear of death. I drowned 26 years ago. I crossed over and saw the real life. We are living on the upside-down-side of reality on this side. I could not feel sad that Chris left, because he knew the truth. But then.. you knocked me down with your poem. A whole new perspective of death entered my mind. The ones departing has no interest to return too soon. The ones behind mourn their own loneliness, awaiting their own departure. But the winds and the hills and the valleys is neither going nor coming. The cosmos itself is hurting the most. Who will replace Leonardo da Vince, who will sing the song of the piper. Will it be Hitler who replace the melody with saluuts and battle cries. Will the H2O force be the chisel of the new artist, changing the future. I need time to absorb all of this.
Dear Tony, perhaps I will write a hub about near death. I can also confirm the deliberate conscious decision to leave life in the right circumstances. Dying is our own choice. If I do this, I would kindly ask if I can make reference to this hub of yours. After all, you have the credit. Because of your poem I have grown in my own understanding.
Merci Tony pour cet émouvant hommage a votre frère.
La musique de Chris et du Brotherhood m'accompagne depuis tellement d'années....
Cordialement.
I knew of Chris, particularly of his struggles fielding mixed bands back then and his exile But I really haven't listened to his music. Listening to him with Brotherhood (via YouTube) as I reread this Hub. A wonderful tribute. Definitely a man who transcends his music.
Tony, I'm the publisher of Maxine's book. I just chanced on this today, and it was nice to read the remembrances and to see pictures of CMcG that I hadn't seen. Of all the books I've published Maxine's may be the one I am most proud of having enabled. Take care, Bill B.
Chris'Music is still alive in my heart. I produced a Concert with Chris, Ernest Mothle, Charles Tyler and Jean Jacques Corriger in my Cinéma In Ste Foy la Grande in 1985 And it's the event I am the most proud of. Chris is a model of human being with all his generosity and joie de vivre. The BoB was the way I tackle with jazz and I will be always reconnaissant for Chris ans his alumny for their great music.
Thank you for your poem
This piece was absolutely beautiful. Such a heartfelt tribute. I absolutely love this. ty so much for sharing ~hugs~










































Nellieanna Level 8 Commenter 21 months ago
Intensely beautiful and so personal. I lost a beautiful, talented sister, her 3 little boys and her husband tragically in a car/train accident when she was only 35 and I was only 21. It was traumatizing. So I can feel some of your sense of loss, Tony. Your poem of remembrance is lovely.